Butterfinger Cookie from Bake The Cookie Shoppe loaded with crushed peanut butter candy bar pieces

Butterfinger Cookie

$5.25
Skip to product information
Butterfinger Cookie from Bake The Cookie Shoppe loaded with crushed peanut butter candy bar pieces
  • Butterfinger Cookie from Bake The Cookie Shoppe loaded with crushed peanut butter candy bar pieces
  • Butterfinger Cookie from Bake The Cookie Shoppe loaded with crushed peanut butter candy bar pieces
Butterfinger Cookie

Butterfinger Cookie

$5.25
  • Ships nationwide Mon–Thu. UPS delivers 1–3 business days after your ship date. Free UPS Ground on $75+.
  • Holiday deadlines: ship by Nov 19 for Thanksgiving, Dec 17 for Christmas.
  • In Las Vegas, Riverside or Tempe? Order pickup or delivery from your store. Find a store
Allergens

bake the Cookie Shoppe cookies are made by hand using shared equipment, which processes dairy, peanuts, soy, tree nuts and wheat. If you have a severe allergy, please know that while we do our best to prevent cross-contamination, we are not an allergy-free bakery.

May contain: dairy, eggs, soy, wheat, peanuts, tree nuts.

Crispy, crunchy, peanut buttery, and loaded from edge to edge.

We fold generous handfuls of crushed Butterfinger candy bars into our rich brown sugar cookie dough, then bake it thick until the edges turn golden and crisp. As it bakes, the candy's flaky peanut butter center melts into caramelized pockets of chocolatey, toffee-like goodness. The chunks that hold their shape keep that signature Butterfinger crunch.

Every bite has a soft, chewy center, crisp golden edges, melty chocolate, and crunchy peanut butter candy.

Enjoy it at room temperature, or warm it for 10–15 seconds in the microwave for melty, gooey candy pockets. It pairs perfectly with a cold glass of milk.

Every cookie is individually packed and sealed for freshness, and is available for local pickup, Las Vegas delivery, or nationwide shipping.

You may also like